On a recent drive, I was telling my guests about the Ntsevu Breakaways, who have been living a nomadic life since leaving their pride at the end of 2021. Despite being relatively young lions, from the start they have been incredible at successfully hunting buffalo. We got onto the topic of their fathers, the Birmingham Males, and reminisced on how incredible, and well-known, the coalition was at also hunting buffalo. I wondered out loud if there was any correlation in the “buffalo hunting” trait, and whether, despite probably seldom watching their fathers hunt buffalo, there had been a trait passed down to the younger lions. In a passing comment, my guest brought up how these lions could be experiencing some kind of genetic memory. This phenomenon stuck with me, and I was excited to see if any research had been conducted, and ultimately if animals truly possess this remarkable capability.
What is Genetic Memory?
Genetic memory refers to the idea that certain behaviours, instincts, or knowledge can be passed down from one generation to the next through genetic material, independent of direct environmental influence or individual learning. In essence, it suggests that ancestral experiences can shape the behaviour and abilities of offspring, even without direct exposure to those experiences. This concept raises complex questions about the nature of inheritance and the extent to which the experiences of our ancestors continue to influence our lives today.
Remembering Robins and Monarchs
While the notion of genetic memory may seem like something out of science fiction, numerous studies have provided compelling evidence to support its existence in various animal species. One such study, conducted by scientists at the University of Cambridge, explored the migratory behaviour of European robins. These birds undertake long-distance migrations each year, travelling thousands of miles to reach their breeding and wintering grounds. Researchers found that even when raised in captivity without any exposure to the migration route, juvenile robins displayed an innate ability to navigate along the same migratory path as their wild counterparts. This suggests that the migratory route is somehow encoded within their genetic material, allowing them to instinctively know where to go without prior experience.
Similarly, research on monarch butterflies has shown evidence of genetic memory in these iconic insects as well. Monarchs undergo a spectacular multi-generational migration, spanning thousands of miles from North America to Mexico and back. Studies have shown that monarchs bred in captivity, several generations removed from their wild ancestors, still retain the ability to navigate along the same migration route as their ancestors. This again implies that information about the migration is passed down through generations, encoded within their genes.
Beyond migration, genetic memory has also been implicated in other aspects of animal behaviour, such as predator avoidance, foraging strategies, and mating rituals. In each case, animals seem to possess an innate understanding of certain behaviours or preferences, despite never having encountered these situations themselves. It is a big long shot, but perhaps this understanding could be where the Ntsevu Breakways and their aptitude for buffalo hunting fit in?
Digging Deeper into Genetics
However, while these studies provide evidence for the existence of genetic memory in animals, the mechanisms underlying this phenomenon are still not properly understood. There is a big argument, which I might be leaning towards, that instead of genetic memory, these flight patterns and preferences for hunting buffalo are just basic animal instincts.
We have something called epigenetics, which is a mechanism where the environment can alter which genes are expressed or not. If an animal goes through some extreme hardship, for example, disease, starvation, drought etc., it could lead to a change in their genetic expression. Some genes might be turned on or off as a response to the sudden change in the environment. These are changes to the blueprint and to the instructions. These changes can in fact be passed on.
For example, the memory of a famine will not be transferred to the offspring, but the effects it had can be passed on. If another famine strikes these offspring might have a better chance at survival due to the experiences of their ancestors.
While the existence of genetic memory in animals may seem extraordinary, evidence from various studies suggests that it is a very real phenomenon. However, it is not as simple as it seems, and there is way too much in-depth science about the genes that, admittedly, I could not fully grasp or attempt to put into a short blog. However, as our understanding of genetics and animal behaviour continues to advance, I think the phenomenon of genetic memory will be an incredibly captivating area of study and will be great to follow to understand the behaviours and changes of animals over time.
A very interesting blog Robyn. Thank you. Definitely food for thought.
Natures adaptations are truly amazing as they unfold in all species that survive over time. Thank you Robyn for your insights.
That’s fascinating, Robyn. While some things could, as you say, be just basic traits, it would be difficult to argue against birds’ migratory routes without some kind of inherited genetic memory.It would be good to return to this topic again in the future.
There are some interesting facts presented in this blog, but it also raises many questions. I suppose this is why it’s an interesting field of study for scientists and research fellows alike. Following on to your example of the robins raised in captivity, who managed to follow the same migratory trail as their wild counterparts, makes me wonder about some of the animals kept in zoos. Would it be possible to take a lion out of captivity and transport it to an African wildlife location in the hopes its genetic makeup would stimulate it to hunt? Just a thought……
Thanks, Robyn, for this interesting blog.
I think that there is probably a mixture of genetic memory in animals, especially with migrating ones, and learning by watching adults hunt, e.g., as in the case of the lions. However, as you wrote, there is a lot of research or better careful observation of wild animals to be done to be sure of this.
Nature is awesome and we can only learn from nature. With the existence of memory is absolutely astounding and I am sure if a person really astounding and if one digs deeper you will learn much more interesting aspects of these amazing animals.
There is a lot of evidence of this in many animal systems and one possible explanation could be that the mitochondrial DNA in the cell cytoplasm gets influenced and then that gene expression is passed along via the mother (producing an egg). Somehow the mitochondria then can influence or control the gene expression in the nuclei of cells of offspring. Even being a geneticist by education and training this all makes my head spin too!
I have always been baffled by how birds know to build a nest ?
As I lay here in my bed, on what I have learned to call a gloomy day. And, I think to myself, “Maybe the memory thing is not as complicated as it seems?” Maybe the Ntsevu lions remember the taste and like the taste of buffalo? Maybe the Birmingham males and Ntsevu lionesses realized it was easier to feed a 22 member pride by killing buffalo than having to hunt impala constantly? And, maybe they realized that buffalo were easier to find than kudu bulls?
Maybe early birds got the worms by finding thawed ground to the south or north of them, depending on the hemisphere or maybe they were simply made to go in the direction of the food sources? Maybe we are trying to humanize animals in understanding things the way we were made? We certainly do that in movies. So, how do we know to get in out of the rain and animals don’t? Maybe 4 prides of lions, a dazzle of zebra, a herd of elephants and numerous insects, mice and so on, all seeking a few caves in the midst of Londolozi or the Sabie Sands would lead to too much violence, so they just put up with the rains? Or, maybe they are simply made to be out in the rain and we place all the other feelings, emotions and thoughts on them, whether those human traits are there or not?
Our trait is to gain knowledge. Is it an automatic thing that we cannot control and is constantly processing things through memory or are we actually in control of it? I say it’s the former and it is actively shaping our future based on our memories, except that we have never figured out how to stop it and choose no war, as opposed to war. Are we humans no better than a pride of lions, in that regard? I think it would be wiser to sort out our mechanisms, rather than those of animals, because they are, now, rarely a threat to us, but we are a constant threat to them, to ourselves and each other, given our consistent and constant internal dialogue, which includes concluding that we are, basically, animals. Might it not be far better to see ourselves as beings, made in the image and likeness of God? This way, we can mean what we say and say what we mean, because we will be, as, I suggest, we always have been, making our world in our own image and likeness. And, since the 1800s, hasn’t our ‘wisdom’ had us conclude that we are animals? How is that going, this ‘law of the jungle’, ‘survival of the fittest’ living?
Our biggest trait, which animals do not seem to possess, is to make ourselves appear to be the victims of everything around us, rather than the masters, generators and inventors of our worlds, based on our viewpoints, which are mere conversations in our heads. Maybe we need to own our own magnificence and be responsible for generating our worlds out of human traits, and pick the ones we most want to see come to fruition; ones that will leave a more peaceful and loving existence for our progeny and the animals with whom we share our lives. I think I’ll go play in the rain, now. It’s not as gloomy as I automatically adapted it to be, given my collective memory.